For a film with subject matter that is so focused on faith, it's surprising that subtle approach to that is almost no where to be seen. The Two Popes has exactly this problem, an intriguing premise and message that becomes overshadowed by questionable filmmaking.
Right off the bat, the cinematography is mind boggling, having an idea of how to represent the meaning of a moment that becomes lost thanks to ludicrous camera focusing and shakiness. The editing doesn't help much, as it feels lost by how much it tries to cram into one scene, especially in the film's first scenes. The way The Two Popes is made simply fails to work for what it aims for, and doesn't seem to realize this; if anything it glorifies it and makes these issues more distracting from the plot.
Thankfully, some of the greatness is reaches for is achieved thanks to great performances. Jonathan Pryce as Pope Francis is a wonderful guide for the film, having the heart and passion needed to bring the character to life. Hopkins is also gives a rather effective turn as Pope Benedict XVI, with the regret and tiredness he carries with him being effortlessly projected into his performance, creating for a powerful performance. The two really carry the film, especially with their chemistry.
There is some genuinely compelling moments between them that save the film from the terrible fate of being (gasp) below average. The bond grows between them becomes fascinating with how they deal with their disagreements and explorations of their faith. This is especially true for Pryce's character, whose backstory offers an interesting insight on regret.
Unfortunately, the screenwriting never allows it to reach its full potential. It feels lost in how to bring to life these situations. It either comes off as overblown in a representation of the gravity of a moment, or tries to pack too much into one scene, especially in some of the film's earlier moments. Had this film had a different screenwriter, it's possible that may of these issues wouldn't have been present, and that the plot would've been much more focused.
The Two Popes ultimately comes off as frustrating, because it has glimpses of a great film, but those are unfortunately never fully realized because it never gets past its approach to filmmaking and writing. Even with two very strong performances that help bring to live some of this greatness, it can rid of the distractions it carries throughout its runtime.
Final Grade: C+
No comments:
Post a Comment